Support independent journalism in Central & Eastern Europe.
Donate to TOL!

× Learn more
No, thanks Photo: Abbas Atilay
 
back  |  printBookmark and Share

Hard to Handle

A plagiarism scandal involving the Minister of Science and Education still stirs Croatia. From Global Voices. by Filip Stojanovski 1 June 2017

Croatian citizens are fed up with public officials with undeserved academic credit, gained thanks to plagiarism.

 

In January, Croatia’s parliament-appointed Committee for Ethics in Science and Higher Education (CESHE) concluded that the current Minister of Science and Education, Pavo Barisic, copied another scholar's work without attribution in a 2011 academic paper.

 

Barisic claimed that it's a matter of a footnote mishap which was corrected in translations of the paper published in Spanish and German, as well as the online version of the Croatian paper.

 

Among many others, internationally renowned molecular biologist Ivan Dikic called upon Croatian Prime Minister Andrej Plenkovic to replace the minister who “deceived the prime minister and the public by claiming it's just a printing mistake”. Dikic published an extensive analysis, with argumentation that the minister plagiarized a text by Stephen Schlesinger, “unethically appropriated ideas” from several books without quoting the sources, copy-pasted contents from Wikipedia, and that even his corrections were inconsistent and faulty.

 

Croatian Minister of Science and Education Pavo Barisic with Prime Minister Andrej Plenkovic in the background. Photo from the website of Government of Republic of Croatia.

 

In February, fact-checking website Faktograf determined that Barisic made the corrections and apologized to Schlesinger after he was caught in the act of plagiarism, and that his explanations of the whole case were misleading and manipulative.

 

The online petition “Stop to Plagiarism in Croatia”, initiated by 19 academics from Croatia, including some working in the USA, UK and Australia, has received 11,639 signatures so far.

 

There is a vast body of evidence that shows that plagiarism is a widespread problem in Croatian academic, educational and public life. Plagiarism and similar kinds of ethically unacceptable behavior have lasting damage on research and educational institutions; further leading to a serious decline in trust.

 

We would like to express deep concern about this state of affairs and ask the Croatian Government and Parliament to enforce a policy of zero tolerance to plagiarism. In particular we ask for a sanctioning of instances of plagiarism committed by those who hold a public office.

 

Faktograf quoted constitutional expert Sanja Baric, who noted that the prime minister should not contradict or ignore the decision of the CESHE. However, the tainted Barisic still holds the post of Croatian minister of science and education.

 

In recent months, official tweets by the Croatian government about science and education have often received comments from citizens who question their credibility.

 

On 12 May, Faktograf published a denial issued by the minister's lawyer, claiming their assessments were inaccurate and that his client is not a plagiarist. Faktograf then fact-checked the claims in the denial, and confirmed they are not based on facts.

 

At a public event on 15 May, the initiators of the online petition reiterated their demands for removal of confirmed plagiarists from the parliament, the constitutional court and the government. Professor Dikic said that widespread plagiarism is like cancer in society — and a form of stealing — which must not be tolerated anywhere.

 

However, having mentioned the case as an example of unsuccessful attempts to influence him while discussing possible changes in his cabinet after the ongoing local elections, the chances are slim that the prime minister will remove Barisic from the post of science minister.

Filip Stojanovski has been in web development since 1995, blogging since 2003 in English and Macedonian, and doing research at information society think tank Metamorphosis.

 

This article originally appeared on the citizen journalism site Global Voices, and is republished under a Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial 3.0 International license.

back  |  printBookmark and Share

TOL PROMOTION

Announcement

  

Going on Assignment in Prague – January 7-15, 2018

Do you have a passion for foreign reporting? Would you like to develop your skills further or simply gain more confidence? This course is aimed at university students, freelance journalists or activists who would like to gain some practical skills in this field. You’ll learn the best tricks of the trade from storytelling and interviewing techniques to locating your sources and incorporating multimedia.

Throughout the course you will be guided by experienced foreign correspondents from media such as Reuters, the BBC, the Financial Times, and the New York Times. You’ll leave equipped with a publishable story to add to your portfolio. Early bird fee available until September 1, 2017. Apply now! or see more info.


MULTIMEDIA PROJECTS

Moldovan diaries

The Moldovan Diaries is a multimedia, interactive examination of the country's ethnic, religious, social and political identities by Paolo Paterlini and Cesare De Giglio.

This innovative approach to story telling gives voice to ordinary people and takes the reader on the virtual trip across Moldovan rural and urban landscapes. 

It is a unique and intimate map of the nation.

RELATED ARTICLES

© Transitions Online 2017. All rights reserved. ISSN 1214-1615
Published by Transitions o.s., Baranova 33, 130 00 Prague 3, Czech Republic.